About EM Sky      Bookshelves      Newsletter      Straight from the Barrel...
photo of river valley with farms
EM Sky: Straight from the Barrel...

Win Free Books!

Free NewsletterSubscribe to Wet Ink...
for exclusive offers
and monthly chances
to win free books!

Sponsored by...

September Releases

The Guild of XenolinguistsThe Guild of Xenolinguistsby Sheila Finch
Released Sept. 1!
PowersPowersby Ursula K. Le Guin
Released Sept. 1!
The Spiral LabyrinthThe Spiral Labyrinthby Matthew Hughes
Released Sept. 1!
Moon FlightsMoon Flightsby Elizabteh Moon
Released Sept. 1!
Now and ForeverNow and Foreverby Ray Bradbury
Released Sept. 4!
Heroes in TrainingHeroes in Trainingedited by
Martin H. Greenberg
and Jim C. Hines
Released Sept. 4!
Little (Grrl) LostLittle (Grrl) Lostby Charles de Lint
Released Sept. 6!
AxisAxisby Robert Charles Wilson
Released Sept. 18!
Invasive ProceduresInvasive Proceduresby Orson Scott Card
and Aaron Johnston
Released Sept. 18!
Making MoneyMaking Moneyby Terry Pratchett
Released Sept. 18!
The Orc KingThe Orc King
by R. A. Salvatore
Released Sept. 25!
AscendanciesAscendanciesby Bruce Sterling
Released Sept. 25!
Leven Thumps and the Eyes of the WantLeven Thumps and
the Eyes of the Want
by Obert Skye
Released Sept. 25!
The Winds of Marble ArchThe Winds
of Marble Arch
by Connie Willis
Released Sept. 25!
Sorcery and the Single GirlSorcery and the Single Girlby Mindy Klasky
Released Oct. 1!

Subscribe

 Get the feed

My AOL
Bloglines
Add to Google
Netvibes
Newsgator
Pageflakes
Rojo
My Yahoo
 Get it by e-mail

Add to Technorati Favorites
Copyright Notice

© Copyright EM Sky 2006-2007
Powered by
Movable Type 4.0

« Win-Win Web - call for comments | Main | Universe in motion »

Reason is a tool - use it wisely

I found the following statement in today's post - Fleshy Bloggers - on The TrueTalk Blog:

[W]e all spoke of making decisions that didn't make economic sense so that we could engage in the kind of meaning-making we crave.  That may not be "smart" but it's what many of us do, daily.

Why would anyone claim that this isn't smart? What on earth is stupid about being happy?

People say this kind of thing all the time, and I'm sure that's why Tom wrote that sentence the way he did. People talk about the "smart" thing to do. They say, "Be reasonable." But the person they're talking to is quite often being perfectly reasonable. They're just applying that reason toward different goals.

Reason is a tool. Like any other tool, learning to use it is one thing. Deciding what to do with it is something else altogether. If you happen to own a table saw, you could use it toward making a birdhouse, or a dresser, or a bookcase (thanks, Dad!), or anything else that strikes your fancy. When did we decide that financial success is the only appropriate goal for reason?

As a talented left-brain thinker myself, I have to take issue with this all-too-common definition of reason. If you decide that what you want more than anything in the world is to swim across the English Channel, no one else can decide whether or not this goal is reasonable. If you apply all of your intellect to the task - planning your needs, stocking your safety boat, executing your training program, etc. - then you are being entirely reasonable. You are applying your reason toward your chosen goal.

I'll even take it one step farther. Any goal that you believe will bring you deep and abiding joy is a reasonable goal. It may be unusual, improbable, incredible, or even previously unimagined, but it is not unreasonable. Reason is a tool. I can't stress that enough. And what better purpose is there for any tool than to be used in the service of joy?

So the next time anyone tries to tell you that your happiness isn't "smart" or "reasonable," just remember that they're a little mixed up about the meaning of "reason." Your happiness may not be their happiness. But it is perfectly reasonable.

Use your reason (as well as your intuition, your experience, your curiosity... we have more than one tool in life!) to determine what will truly bring you joy. As you create your dreams, use every tool at your disposal, including reason, to pursue those dreams with everything you have.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.mindunbound.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/emsky/managed-mt/mt-tb.cgi/19

Comments (5)

Kris:

I really like the idea that reason is a tool and not a state of being (reasonable). I've never thought about it that way before.

It's anxiety-inducing to people when you're being "unreasonable" (i.e. trying for something unusual). Do you think that the admonishment to be "reasonable" is really a plea for predictability?

That's an interesting thought, Kris. I do think that predictability has something to do with it. On the one hand there's a certain desire for predictability, but I also think there's a sort of assumption of predictability we often make that gets in our way.

We tend to approach the world around us - and the people around us - as though they were static. If we assume that the world is static, then our "reason" tells us that new ventures are "unreasonable." But of course this is the "reasonable" result of false assumptions.

If we could hold in our minds the assumption that the universe is constantly changing - that the people around us are constantly growing - then we would tend to react to new ventures with a sense of expectation rather than disbelief.

Thanks for the dialogue! I'm going to have to write a new post on this.

- EM

Jack Cook:

Wonderful thought! Perhaps some care must be taken with the word "reason". I assume, of course, that you are using it in the "action" sense, thinking in an orderly, rational way. Webster's Ninth does a great job of articulating its uses.

I love the phrase "reason is a tool." We all too often leave that tool just hanging on our life's pegboard.

Lol. The pegboard of life! I love it!

Thanks for the great image,
EM

Alexander Palk:

One's first step in wisdom is to question everything - and one's last is to come to terms with everything.

Post a comment

Mind Unbound: toward the unimagined truth (SM)